- The Conversion Ledger
- Posts
- The Surprising Reason Your Product Page Isn’t Converting
The Surprising Reason Your Product Page Isn’t Converting
Simple adjustments can help you stop losing customers, sometimes.
Reducing Cognitive Load on PDPs to Improve Conversions
Product Detail Pages (PDPs) are often packed with helpful information aimed at assisting customers in making decisions. However, too much of this good thing can actually overwhelm visitors, creating confusion and hurting conversions. The trick is knowing which details truly help and which ones unintentionally add stress.
To tackle this issue, we've created an easy-to-follow guide below. You'll discover common mistakes that clutter your pages, practical tools to assess user experience, and simple methods to keep things clear and user-friendly.
Common Clutter to Avoid
PDPs often get cluttered with seemingly useful elements that actually cause confusion. Watch out for:
Too many or unclear badges/icons
Stick with common badges like trust icons (padlocks) and star ratings. Avoid custom badges without clear context.
FAQs placed too high
FAQs are helpful but keep them lower on the page for users seeking more detailed info.
Long text blocks
Large paragraphs create friction. Break them down into bullet points or highlight keywords.
Overly complicated layouts
Ensure elements have enough space, especially on mobile, to prevent frustrating clicks.
Unnecessary payment details
Save icons and "buy-now-pay-later" options for checkout unless it's a high-priced item.
How to Evaluate Your PDP
Here’s how you can quickly check if your PDP is clear or cluttered:
Use session recordings and heatmaps
Tools like Hotjar reveal user confusion through rage clicks, excessive mouse hovering, or highlighting text.
Apply Hick’s Law
Limit the number of decisions by visually indicating unavailable options clearly (like color or size).
Run usability checks
Regularly review your PDP’s clarity and layout to identify friction points.
Simplify your content
Make sure text is concise, clear, and easy to scan.
Simplifying Your PDP Effectively
Improving your PDP requires smartly removing, repositioning, or emphasizing key content:
Remove
Ditch any repetitive visuals, unnecessary text, and excess icons near important areas like the buy box.
Reposition
Move detailed FAQs, long descriptions, and payment info down the page. Place user-generated content strategically based on brand familiarity.
Highlight clearly
Place guarantees, shipping, and returns clearly near the "Add to Cart" button. Make sure product options like size, color, and subscription choices are easy to select.
Additionally, make sure to:
Offer a brief description upfront, with extended details lower on the page.
Use high-quality images, ideally interactive views, to showcase products clearly.
Clearly communicate free shipping and return policies.
Keeping your PDP clean and intuitive helps your customers make easy decisions, and easy decisions mean more conversions.
Loss from the Past: Not every good thing is good everywhere
After a string of wins revamping PDP Buy Boxes, we thought we’d carry those learnings to another client and stack on another win like Max Verstappen. Except, we didn’t. In fact, it was more like a crash into the wall on the first lap. It was so bad we stopped it early as it would have resulted in a $2.4MM loss.
What we did:
New, larger font for readability
Added average star reviews below the product name
Changed dropdowns into tapable button options
Gave more visual weight to “add to cart” text
Highlighted free shipping and returns below the ATC
Moved long product description below the ATC button
Moved breadcrumbs to top left corner
Added “customers also loved these” product rec carousel below the fold

All of the loss came from new visitors, with a -13.5% decrease in transactions.
Add to carts were down -6.3%, and visits to Checkout were down -7%.
The data suggested the “Customers Also Loved These” section encouraged v1 visitors to explore more product pages, distracting them from adding to cart and checking out.
Just because something has done well for multiple other brands does not mean it will do well for you.
Quote of the week:
“Understanding a person’s hunger and responding to it is one of the most potent tools you’ll ever discover for getting through to anyone you meet in business or your personal life.”
Key Takeaways
Reducing cognitive load means keeping PDPs clear, simple, and user-friendly. Remember to:
Clearly contextualize badges/icons and avoid frequent changes.
Place detailed and supplementary information strategically lower on the page.
Regularly evaluate page usability through heatmaps, session recordings, and usability scorecards.
Utilize cognitive principles such as Hick’s Law to simplify decision-making.
Clearly organize and visually emphasize essential decision-making elements and conversion-driving details.
Thoughtful implementation of these practices will directly boost your conversion rates and improve customer satisfaction.
Looking forward,
Brian

How valuable was this week's newsletter? |
P.S. Ready to improve your conversion rate but don’t know where to begin or don’t have the team to support it? Let’s talk.